In light of the continual blogger discussion about circumcision, I just had to stir up some crap with my own post on the issue. So many people are afraid to offend other people on their blogs. Quite frankly, I don’t give a damn. I love mature, adult discussions about the most controversial of issues. So, lets have one. Beware: I will be sharing with you my strong opinions on the issue. I’m totally cool with it if you disagree. Just be nice about it. I have friends who have circumcised. I do not judge them. I do not think they are bad parents. I do not think their children are psychologically ruined for life. While I don’t agree, it was their decision and they can’t change it now anyway. So be it. This is my blog. This is my opinion.
In this video, Penn & Teller explore circumcision.
(Warning: This one made me gag. People do this to their sons. Still. In light of all the research.) This video shows a routine infant circumcision, in case you don’t want to take the time to watch the above.
But you really should.
It’s all about education.
And? The Penn & Teller one is really freaking entertaining.
Except the part where they painfully mutilate the genitals of a newborn baby.
Okay, I guess I gave away my stance on the issue. I think I’ll go with the argument/counter argument method. Please feel free to politely add your own in comments. Again, I don’t care if you agree with me, or if you even have a strong opinion. I just love controversy. (And I’d never cut any part of my baby off without some serious medical reason…arm, leg, penis…get my drift?)
I think it’s akin to female genital mutilation. It’s surgery. Unnecessary surgery at that.
———-
Watch the second video. Imagine them doing that to your son, while you watch. Imagine them doing the corresponding thing to your daughter, while you watch. ["But I wouldn't watch! I could never watch that!"] Ahem. Point made.
[I want my son to look like his daddy.] (Thirty years ago, this procedure was routine. Many parents weren’t even asked before their sons were stolen away to be mutilated.) (No, I can’t call it “snipped” or “cut.” Those are cutesie words. This is major genital surgery. Not cute. Not snippy snip snip.) My husband’s answer to that one: “I’m pretty sure we won’t be sitting around comparing dicks much. I have lots of great memories with my dad, none of which involve his penis. If he has a problem with his dick not looking like mine, we’ve done something else seriously wrong.”
[They won't remember the pain/They don't feel pain.] They won’t remember if you punch them in the head either. That doesn’t make it right. And to the second point? Um. Bullshit.
[It reduces the risk of AIDS. [insert STD here]] Not if you use a condom. Then it becomes a non-issue. Isn’t this what we should be teaching our kids anyway?
[You can't get penis cancer if you're circumcised. Penis cancer almost always occurs in the foreskin.] You can’t get breast cancer if you don’t have tits. Go cut them off, mmm-kay? While you’re at it, I think nose cancer is getting more common.
[It's easier to keep clean.] No, it’s not. There’s no work to cleaning a baby penis (unless, of course, you hack part of it off, in which case you have to deal with blood, scar tissue, pain…) You just clean it like you clean their fingers and toes. Nothing to it. It will retract anywhere between the ages of 3 and 13, at which time you teach them to clean it. No different than a vagina (there are way more folds in a vagina, actually) and we don’t hack part of them off to make them easier to clean.
[I just don't want him to be made fun of/feel different...] First of all, the kids with part of their dicks chopped off are different. Second, how about we foster self confidence in our kids. And maybe teach them a few snarky comebacks for others who either spend their free time looking at other kids’ penises or are interested enough to keep talking about them. That should do it.
[I'll let my husband make the decision. He's the one with a penis, after all.] You grew this kid. You both had a part in making him. These decisions need to be made together. Look at all side of the issue. Remember, we’re in a different society now than even 20 years ago. The mother’s instinct is to protect her children from pain. Not to pay other people to cause it.
[I prefer the look of it. I want his future partners to like the look of his wang.] First of all, ew. You don’t want to be thinking about your future son’s sex life. Really. You also have no idea what his partner(s) will prefer. If he {and I repeat HE} wants to chop it off in the future, it belongs to him and he can do so. If he likes it the way it is, great. If you mutilate it and he wants it back, he has to go through a hell of a lot to get it back. Again, from my husband’s perspective…”If our kid is obsessed with his dick and is comparing it to others’, we’ve done something wrong.”
[When he's really old he might end up not being able to clean his penis properly and then it will get all smelly and gross.] What about your unclean, smelly and gross vagina when you’re 95? Hopefully someone will clean it for you before it gets that bad, as they hopefully will to his penis if he is unable. However, NOT a reason to cut part of it off. What if he’s healthy and can clean it properly until he leaves the earth? You never know. You wouldn’t cut off all of your daughters’ extra genital skin in preparation for their life in a nursing home, would you?
———-
So, there you have it. My very biased educated opinion on the issue. I also should tell you that I always thought I would circumcise any of my sons, just because it’s what I was used to and I had fallen prey so the infamous pressure of society. When I was pregnant we read a lot of research (not blogger opinions; actual research) and spoke to many doctors about it and decided we would not do it for all of the above reasons and more. Then, when I held my precious newborn son in my arms I knew we had made the right decision. There was no way I would ever let anyone hurt him, let alone pay them to do it.
(more…)